I talk a lot on this blog about the initial Gothic heyday at the turn of the nineteenth century, which sprung up after the publication of Horace Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto and brought us such authors as Ann Radcliffe, Matthew Lewis, and William Beckford. But these days when you mention the Gothic to someone not overly familiar with the genre, they may picture a more recent heyday: the boom of Gothic romance and suspense novels in the mid-twentieth century, many of them mass-produced by a handful of genre-focused publishers. These books are perhaps best remembered today for their evocatively illustrated covers that employed common visual tropes such as a fleeing woman in a diaphanous dress or nightgown, a looming manor castle in the background, and a single illuminated window peering out like an eye. The book most often credited with kicking off this boom is Mistress of Mellyn by Victoria Holt. Continue reading Classics: Mistress of Mellyn
Category: Gothic Romance
Review of A Lady for a Duke—Queer Regency Romance
A brooding duke in a lonely, windswept castle—at first glance, the Duke of Gracewood appears to be your typical Gothic Romance hero. But Viola Carroll already knows the good-hearted and sensitive man that lies beneath this gruff exterior. If only he could see Viola for who she truly was…. A Lady for a Duke is a queer Regency romance that came out last year and is my first experience with the work of the prolific and versatile Alexis Hall, though I’ve long been aware of his stature in the genre. If you love romance novels that pull at your heartstrings and seeing trans characters represented in historical contexts, don’t miss this one! Continue reading Review of A Lady for a Duke—Queer Regency Romance
Review of The Ghost and Mrs Muir—Midcentury Ghost Romance
Would you move into a haunted cottage? For Lucy Muir, the ghost of a grumpy old sea captain turns out to be just what she needed to complete her picture of perfect domestic bliss in The Ghost and Mrs Muir. The novel was published by Irish author Josephine Leslie under the pseudonym R. A. Dick in 1945. It was adapted into a popular film in 1947, directed by Joseph L. Mankiewicz and starring Gene Tierney and Rex Harrison. If you’re looking for something sweet, slow, and low-stakes to read this summer, definitely check out this classic! Continue reading Review of The Ghost and Mrs Muir—Midcentury Ghost Romance
Review of Lakesedge—Monsters and Magic in YA Gothic
What would you trade for the power to protect those you love? Violeta bargains with gods and monsters in Lyndall Clipstone’s debut YA novel, Lakesedge. Described as a “lush gothic fantasy,” Lakesedge comes out tomorrow, September 28. Continue reading Review of Lakesedge—Monsters and Magic in YA Gothic
Review of The Haunting of Craigmorag Castle
Even Gothic romance authors deserve a Gothic romance of their own. Lisa Greer gets meta about the genre in her self-published romance novel, The Haunting of Craigmorag Castle, which came out earlier this year. If you’re looking for something fun to read this summer that blends the sweet and silly with the spooky and atmospheric, give this one a shot! Continue reading Review of The Haunting of Craigmorag Castle
Review of John Eyre—Monsters in the Attic
How many times can one Gothic novel be retold? If that novel is Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre—a story that spawned other great classics like Daphne du Maurier’s Rebecca and served as a blueprint for the entire genre of mid-century Gothic romance pulps—I think its generative capabilities are endless. One of the latest authors to put her own spin on Jane Eyre is Mimi Matthews, with John Eyre: A Tale of Darkness and Shadow, coming out tomorrow, July 20. From the title, you might guess that this is a gender-swapped retelling, but it’s actually much more than that: John Eyre uses the familiar beats of Brontë’s classic (along with elements from a few other Gothic novels) to tell an entirely different story. I am thrilled to have been invited to participate in the official blog tour for this book’s release, because I need more friends to geek out about this charming and clever reimagining with! Continue reading Review of John Eyre—Monsters in the Attic
Review of The Wife in the Attic—A Sapphic Jane Eyre
What if the governess fell in love with … the wife in the attic? This is essentially the premise of Rose Lerner’s new novel The Wife in the Attic, which was just released as an Audible Original last month. I’ve been devouring audiobooks like candy since the start of the pandemic, so what could be better than a queer reimagining of one of my favorite Gothic novels released exclusively in audio? And as someone who has always been way more sympathetic toward Bertha Mason than Mr. Rochester, The Wife in the Attic was everything I could ask for. Continue reading Review of The Wife in the Attic—A Sapphic Jane Eyre
The Gentleman and the Thief Review
A music teacher who moonlights as a sneak thief and a penniless gentleman with a knack for uncovering secrets—what could possibly go wrong? The Gentleman and the Thief by Sarah M. Eden is the sequel to The Lady and the Highwayman, one of my favorite books from 2019. I’ve been keeping this cozy historical romance at the ready to serve as a comfort read during this dark and dreary winter, and I’m so glad I did. This book had everything I’ve come to expect from the Dread Penny Society series: an abundance of mystery, a sweet courtship between two lovable protagonists, and a clever interplay with the uniquely Victorian literary phenomenon of the penny dreadful. If you need to keep the love going post–Valentine’s Day, I can’t recommend this series enough! Continue reading The Gentleman and the Thief Review
Review of Mexican Gothic
Who says the Gothic has to be relegated to creepy old castles in Europe? While American Gothic has been an established subset of the genre since the nineteenth century, in recent years the Gothic has really expanded into a diversity of settings and perspectives. Celebrated Mexican-Canadian author Silvia Moreno-Garcia brings classic Gothic tropes and story structures into the Mexican countryside in the straightforwardly titled Mexican Gothic, which came out earlier this summer. Continue reading Review of Mexican Gothic
Review of The Lawrence Browne Affair
A mad scientist locks himself in his tower in the Cornish countryside, until a rakish thief comes to steal his heart. The Lawrence Browne Affair by Cat Sebastian, which came out back in 2017, is a sweet and powerful queer romance set in the Regency era. I’m pretty new to the world of m/m historical romance, but the Romancing the Gothic book club seems to have fallen into this niche lately, and all of our picks have been quite good! This was definitely the kind of heartwarming read I needed as we head into another month of quarantine. Continue reading Review of The Lawrence Browne Affair